THE UNIVERSAL PRAYER FOR CHRISTIAN UNITY
Abbé Couturier was born into a strong Catholic family in the historic City of Lyons in France on 29th July 1881. The city had a long history encompassing science and medicine, and Paul’s father owned a chemical factory on the Banks of the River Rhône. The city, like Magdeburg, had a rich ecclesiastical history for both Catholics and Protestants. Much of this had an impact on Paul Couturiers later life. Two Popes were elected In Lyons, and two official Church councils took place in the city. The Second Council of Lyons in 1274 called by Pope Gergory X signaled the brief reunion of the Orthodox Church of the East and the Latin Western Church. Lyons was also the city of “ Protestant’ Peter Waldo (1140-1217) and his community who were called the ‘Poor Men of Lyons’. Like St Francis, Waldo preached a type of radical apostolic poverty and biblical devotion. His group were however excommunicated and only managed to survive by taking refuge in the Italian Alps. Many years later they joined the Reformation movement and created the Waldensian Church.
At the age of nineteen Paul decided to become a priest. After a novitiate of one year and four years theology, he was ordained a priest on 9 June 1906 in the Society of Saint Irenaeus, a company of mission and teaching priests.[1] He found the daily celebration of Mass an ‘événement’ which led to copious reflections on the mysteries of faith. It was decided by the superiors in the Society that Paul should become a schoolteacher and for this he did some studies in mathematics and the exact sciences. With his scientific intellectual background, robust faith and vivid imagination, his life was marked by a profound sense of prayer. Among his inspirations was the pioneering work of the Jesuit Priest -scientist Pierre Teilhard de Chardin and his essay on the spiritual life – The Milieu Divin – an Essay on the Interior Life. This writing brought together ideas of scientific discovery and spirituality.
Something that gave the schoolteacher a challenging impetus was a ministry caring for some Russian Émigrés who had escaped Russia after the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917. As a result of an Ignatian retreat he experienced in his early twenties, he undertook some relief work with the refugees and was able to meet and have fellowship with Orthodox priests and archpriests as well as their communities who had fled for safety to Lyons. This work with the Orthodox taught him the need for a ministry of Christian Unity. His Apostolate was not so much of service or supplying practical needs but of opening his heart and understanding the sentiments of those who were living in abject poverty, far from their former churchly importance in Russian society. He was able to establish trust and friendship with them, and, through this, Paul became aware of the liturgical theological and spiritual richness of Eastern Orthodoxy. From them he learnt a saying of Metropolitan Platon Gorodetsky (1803-1891) that ‘the walls of separation do not rise as far as heaven’. [2] This became a strong principle and motivation in Couturiers’ own theology and praxis and gave him the idea of propagating a Church Unity Octave for Catholics, Protestants and Orthodox. He clarified where he first got his inspiration in a letter to Swedish Pastor Rosendal
The origin of this movement is in fact the Otave of the Atonement, pure and simple which you have seen in The Lamp ( the magazine of Fr Paul Wattson) but I have shown how it must be broadened and decentralized, and how Providence blesses this broadening this purely evangelical concentration. [3]
He decided to write to Rev. Spencer Jones who was one of the Founders of the Octave with Fr Wattson:
You know how much I desire the increasing success of the Church Unity Octave which is your work; and it is a magnificent work, and I pray for its success but I have a profound conviction of the absolute necessity of Universal Prayer. May God bless both movements for His Glory alone. [4]
Abbé Couturier had found that most Christians found the aims of the Octave founded by Rev Jones and Fr Paul Watting too narrow by focusing on the Papal basis for reunion which, for many, was an insuperable barrier to any participation. He rather felt there was a need for a formula which did not offend any denominational sensibilities or loyalties. Rather, he felt, it should be a formula to which every Christian could subscribe to, of whatever religious tradition or background. For this he proposed a name change to the Week of Universal Prayer of Christians for Christian Unity. [5]In 1938 he wrote:
Have you not, as I have , the unshakeable conviction that God is waiting for this Universal Prayer, modulated according to different spiritualities, springing forth at this one sorrowful point of Christian divisions just in order that all Christians through prayers sincere and loyal may receive from Him the gift of recovered unity. [6]
[1] https://www.catholicireland.net/apostle-of-christian-unity-fr-paul-couturier-1881-1953/
[2] https://mission4unity.com/interdenominational/ Platon was the former Metropolitan of Kiev and Galacia
[3] Curtis, Geoffrey Paul Coururier and Unity in Christ Eckenrode Westminster SCM UK 1964 p.63
[4] Op. Cit. p. 64
[5] Op. Cit. p. 65
[6][6] Op. Cit. p. 65
At the age of nineteen Paul decided to become a priest. After a novitiate of one year and four years theology, he was ordained a priest on 9 June 1906 in the Society of Saint Irenaeus, a company of mission and teaching priests.[1] He found the daily celebration of Mass an ‘événement’ which led to copious reflections on the mysteries of faith. It was decided by the superiors in the Society that Paul should become a schoolteacher and for this he did some studies in mathematics and the exact sciences. With his scientific intellectual background, robust faith and vivid imagination, his life was marked by a profound sense of prayer. Among his inspirations was the pioneering work of the Jesuit Priest -scientist Pierre Teilhard de Chardin and his essay on the spiritual life – The Milieu Divin – an Essay on the Interior Life. This writing brought together ideas of scientific discovery and spirituality.
Something that gave the schoolteacher a challenging impetus was a ministry caring for some Russian Émigrés who had escaped Russia after the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917. As a result of an Ignatian retreat he experienced in his early twenties, he undertook some relief work with the refugees and was able to meet and have fellowship with Orthodox priests and archpriests as well as their communities who had fled for safety to Lyons. This work with the Orthodox taught him the need for a ministry of Christian Unity. His Apostolate was not so much of service or supplying practical needs but of opening his heart and understanding the sentiments of those who were living in abject poverty, far from their former churchly importance in Russian society. He was able to establish trust and friendship with them, and, through this, Paul became aware of the liturgical theological and spiritual richness of Eastern Orthodoxy. From them he learnt a saying of Metropolitan Platon Gorodetsky (1803-1891) that ‘the walls of separation do not rise as far as heaven’. [2] This became a strong principle and motivation in Couturiers’ own theology and praxis and gave him the idea of propagating a Church Unity Octave for Catholics, Protestants and Orthodox. He clarified where he first got his inspiration in a letter to Swedish Pastor Rosendal
The origin of this movement is in fact the Otave of the Atonement, pure and simple which you have seen in The Lamp ( the magazine of Fr Paul Wattson) but I have shown how it must be broadened and decentralized, and how Providence blesses this broadening this purely evangelical concentration. [3]
He decided to write to Rev. Spencer Jones who was one of the Founders of the Octave with Fr Wattson:
You know how much I desire the increasing success of the Church Unity Octave which is your work; and it is a magnificent work, and I pray for its success but I have a profound conviction of the absolute necessity of Universal Prayer. May God bless both movements for His Glory alone. [4]
Abbé Couturier had found that most Christians found the aims of the Octave founded by Rev Jones and Fr Paul Watting too narrow by focusing on the Papal basis for reunion which, for many, was an insuperable barrier to any participation. He rather felt there was a need for a formula which did not offend any denominational sensibilities or loyalties. Rather, he felt, it should be a formula to which every Christian could subscribe to, of whatever religious tradition or background. For this he proposed a name change to the Week of Universal Prayer of Christians for Christian Unity. [5]In 1938 he wrote:
Have you not, as I have , the unshakeable conviction that God is waiting for this Universal Prayer, modulated according to different spiritualities, springing forth at this one sorrowful point of Christian divisions just in order that all Christians through prayers sincere and loyal may receive from Him the gift of recovered unity. [6]
[1] https://www.catholicireland.net/apostle-of-christian-unity-fr-paul-couturier-1881-1953/
[2] https://mission4unity.com/interdenominational/ Platon was the former Metropolitan of Kiev and Galacia
[3] Curtis, Geoffrey Paul Coururier and Unity in Christ Eckenrode Westminster SCM UK 1964 p.63
[4] Op. Cit. p. 64
[5] Op. Cit. p. 65
[6][6] Op. Cit. p. 65
THE UNIVERSAL PRAYER OF CHRISTIANS FOR CHRISTIAN UNITY
THE UNIVERSAL PRAYER FOR CHRISTIANS FOR CHRISTIAN UNITY
Initially Abbé Couturier decided on three days of prayer – a Triduum for the Return to Unity from 20-22 January 1933 which took place at the Church of Saint Francis de Sales in Lyon. It included liturgical music in Latin alternating with Russian. The hope was that little by little, misunderstandings which had come from history would be healed at the Cradle of Christ. The following year in 1934 the Triduum became a ‘ solemn octave of Prayer from 18-25 January. There were present hundreds of Orthodox in the Cathedral and the crowd could not be seated in the available space. Père Salet SJ used the sermon text that Saint Bonaventure had used in 1274 in the same Cathedral at the time of the Council of Lyons
‘ Lift up thyself, O Sion, and gaze toward the East; behold thy children that had departed return to thee’ ( Baruch 5:5)’ [1]
Père Salet then spoke of the failure to heal the divisions in the Church over the previous 700 years since the Council of Lyons. Something more was needed. He said:
There was need for the initiative of the Church to be supported by something lacking in the Middle Ages – the great orchestra of the Spirit provided by the people of Christ. There must be a preparation on the part of the bulk of the Church in prayer and longing for reconciliation, if the complementary treasures of truth, East and Wast are to find their unity in Christ.
Sadly, the presence of the Orthodox in the Catholic Cathedral received negative criticism, leaving Abbé isolated in his ecumenical vision. The experience of this suffering caused him however to become more resolute in his commitment to the Word of God and to his cause of unity. He realized that every in Christian community there was a struggle between loyalty to one’s own confession and the hope and aim of unity. In view of this partisanship wouldn’t it be better he surmised to have a week of devotion simply called ‘ For Christian Unity’? He also regretted the inability of the Church to confess the guilt of the Church for the Crusades or to respond properly to the aims of the reformers. He said:
If only since the separation there had been a compensation – an immense, intense, inexhaustible expiation by means of humble prayer and penitence! But no, up to this moment there is no great general movement, no new style of crusade in which the countless army of the faithful, the cross of reunion on their breast, take for their weapons humiliation for admitted sin ( ‘in all and al men, for all and all men we are guilty of all’ said Dostoevsky) humiliation, prayer and penitence. [2]
Therefore, he regarded with such a sense of humility and contrition there comes what is a golden rule:
We understand this Octave of prayers of each Christian confession in full liberty and independence; but excluding anything far or near which could harm the spiritual independence of liberty on any to keep the Octave is to make spiritual preparation for the Reunion desired by the very manner of praying for it. [3]
The Octave cannot therefore be specifically Catholic and must not be monopolized by Catholics. It needs three psychological pillars:
[1] Op. Cit p. 67 [2] Op. Cit. p. 74[3] Op. Cit p. 74[4] Op. Cit. p.76
Initially Abbé Couturier decided on three days of prayer – a Triduum for the Return to Unity from 20-22 January 1933 which took place at the Church of Saint Francis de Sales in Lyon. It included liturgical music in Latin alternating with Russian. The hope was that little by little, misunderstandings which had come from history would be healed at the Cradle of Christ. The following year in 1934 the Triduum became a ‘ solemn octave of Prayer from 18-25 January. There were present hundreds of Orthodox in the Cathedral and the crowd could not be seated in the available space. Père Salet SJ used the sermon text that Saint Bonaventure had used in 1274 in the same Cathedral at the time of the Council of Lyons
‘ Lift up thyself, O Sion, and gaze toward the East; behold thy children that had departed return to thee’ ( Baruch 5:5)’ [1]
Père Salet then spoke of the failure to heal the divisions in the Church over the previous 700 years since the Council of Lyons. Something more was needed. He said:
There was need for the initiative of the Church to be supported by something lacking in the Middle Ages – the great orchestra of the Spirit provided by the people of Christ. There must be a preparation on the part of the bulk of the Church in prayer and longing for reconciliation, if the complementary treasures of truth, East and Wast are to find their unity in Christ.
Sadly, the presence of the Orthodox in the Catholic Cathedral received negative criticism, leaving Abbé isolated in his ecumenical vision. The experience of this suffering caused him however to become more resolute in his commitment to the Word of God and to his cause of unity. He realized that every in Christian community there was a struggle between loyalty to one’s own confession and the hope and aim of unity. In view of this partisanship wouldn’t it be better he surmised to have a week of devotion simply called ‘ For Christian Unity’? He also regretted the inability of the Church to confess the guilt of the Church for the Crusades or to respond properly to the aims of the reformers. He said:
If only since the separation there had been a compensation – an immense, intense, inexhaustible expiation by means of humble prayer and penitence! But no, up to this moment there is no great general movement, no new style of crusade in which the countless army of the faithful, the cross of reunion on their breast, take for their weapons humiliation for admitted sin ( ‘in all and al men, for all and all men we are guilty of all’ said Dostoevsky) humiliation, prayer and penitence. [2]
Therefore, he regarded with such a sense of humility and contrition there comes what is a golden rule:
We understand this Octave of prayers of each Christian confession in full liberty and independence; but excluding anything far or near which could harm the spiritual independence of liberty on any to keep the Octave is to make spiritual preparation for the Reunion desired by the very manner of praying for it. [3]
The Octave cannot therefore be specifically Catholic and must not be monopolized by Catholics. It needs three psychological pillars:
- A Confiteor sustained by all in humility, prayer and penitence which are independent but convergent.
- The necessarily ecumenical aim of this convergence. It is unity with all in Christ that each group is seeking.
- The scrupulous conservation of radical independence of the theological traditions concerned despite the common ecumenicity. [4]
[1] Op. Cit p. 67 [2] Op. Cit. p. 74[3] Op. Cit p. 74[4] Op. Cit. p.76